People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great spot to stop in and have some DELICIOUS food! Came in on a trip for an appointment at Strong Memorial, this place was right down the road, AMAZINGLY friendly servers and bartenders! They were quick to see our needs were met, and ensured we were happy with our meals. The food was amazing, a total 10 out of 10, the Steak Burger is to die for. Would definitely recommend this restaurant if you’re looking for somewhere to sit and unwind for a bit!l, oh and definitely get stuffed! ”
“ My wife and I have been eating here for years. We just ordered in for the night and it was something special. Incredible fry job on the katsu and buffalo chicken salad. Old Stone has historically had a really solid kitchen but god damn this was even a step above the usual ”
“ The pub boasts a lively yet cozy atmosphere, featuring rustic wooden furnishings, cozy booths, and an array of memorabilia that reflect both Irish culture and the local flair of Florence. ”
“ My new favorite place for food! The food is great never had a bad meal here. The servers and wait staff are friendly and courtious. Im hoping theybwill be around a long time. Cheers!! ”
“ This place was packed at 1:30pm which gives me good vibes but it looked like they only had 2 folks running around so it took them a sec to get to me. I had their jumbo chicken tenders with pub fries. Excellent! Crispy and flavorful! Great work guys! Definitely will return. ”
“ Great service. We came in on a Sunday night where they just had a semi snowstorm so it wasn't too busy. We enjoyed the cauliflower bites with Korean bbq sauce And kiddo enjoyed her burger with normal fries and I my dish platter with sweet potatoes fries ”
“ The food was delicious! Our waitress was very good! I had the onion rings and mozzarella sticks. Both were great! ”
“ If you like tots, this is Tot Heaven! We got Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos, Fried Chicken and Biscuits and a lot of Tots. Everything was delicious. Oh, and 2 pictures of Mimosas. ”
Menu
Funnel Cake Fries
US$9.50The Fish Fry
US$16.95Veggie Beyond Burger
US$15.95Hot Honey Fried Chicken
US$15.95Grilled Chicken Sandwich
US$14.95
About
The Old Stone Tavern
Welcome to The Old Stone Tavern, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Rochester, NY, at 758 South Ave. This charming pub is much more than just a dining destination; it's a warm escape filled with wonderful food and a friendly atmosphere that invites you to unwind and enjoy every moment.
The appeal of The Old Stone Tavern shines through its cozy setting, adorned with rustic wooden furnishings and an array of memorabilia that exquisitely blend Irish culture with local flair. As you step inside, you'll immediately sense a lively yet relaxed vibe, making it the perfect spot to settle in after a long day or to catch up with friends over delicious fare.
Food lovers take note! Diners rave about the menu, showcasing culinary excellence from classic pub fare to unique offerings. Customer Takoda Sackett encourages all to indulge in the renowned Steak Burger, declaring it a "total 10 out of 10." Meanwhile, alex baer highlights the exceptional fry job on the katsu and buffalo chicken salad, praising the kitchen for delivering consistently fantastic food, even during takeout nights.
What truly sets The Old Stone Tavern apart is its dedication to service. Visitors like Denny Halopka and Omar Pachas commend the friendly and attentive staff, who work tirelessly to ensure every guest feels valued and satisfied. Despite busy times, the staff maintains a positive atmosphere, ensuring your needs are met with a smile.
Whether you’re looking for a nutritious meal or a flavorful pub snack, The Old Stone Tavern beckons you with open arms. With its delectable dishes and warm hospitality, it is no wonder that patrons regard it as their new favorite dining spot. So, next time you’re in the area—perhaps after an appointment at nearby Strong Memorial—be sure to visit The Old Stone Tavern and treat yourself to an experience that delights all the senses.
Book a table